top of page
Latest News


Labour Appeal Court Clarifies the Difference Between Procedural and Substantive Unfairness
Can a dismissal be procedurally unfair but substantively fair in South Africa? The Labour Appeal Court's 2026 ruling in Universal Product Network v Mbatsana confirms that procedural defects do not automatically invalidate a fair reason for dismissal. Discover how the Court distinguished procedural and substantive unfairness, overturned the reinstatement of more than 250 employees and upheld the CCMA's original compensation award.

Jonathan Goldberg
Nov 43 min read


Labour Court Upholds Dismissal Over ‘Screw You’ Outburst
Can an employee be dismissed for telling their boss “screw you” in South Africa? In Jenecker v SA Medical and Education Foundation NPC, the Labour Court upheld the dismissal of an employee who publicly directed the phrase at her CEO and deliberately repeated it when challenged. The judgment explains the distinction between insolence and insubordination, when disrespectful workplace conduct can amount to gross misconduct, and when dismissal may be a fair sanction.

Jonathan Goldberg
Oct 83 min read
bottom of page
