top of page

Court Finds Breakdown in Trust Made Reinstatement Intolerable

Writer: Jonathan Goldberg
Jonathan Goldberg
6 days ago
3 min read

In the matter of Golden Arrow Bus Services (Pty) Ltd v Commission for Conciliation Mediation and Arbitration and Others (CA10/2024) [2025] ZALAC 38; [2025] 9 BLLR 915 (LAC); (2025) 46 ILJ 2093 (LAC) the Labour Appeal Court (LAC) has overturned a Labour Court (LC) ruling that reinstated a former senior manager of the employer, finding that the employment relationship had broken down to such an extent that reinstatement was not appropriate.


The matter arose from the troubled rollout of the employer’s smartcard ticketing system in October 2018. The employee served as the company’s support services manager and was responsible for implementing the new system. Despite assurances that the rollout was on track, the employee took annual leave shortly before the launch date. When the system went live, serious problems emerged, including a shortage of cards and the disappearance of approximately 18 000 smartcards.


Upon his return to work, the employee attended a meeting with senior management to address the issues. According to the judgment, he refused to cooperate with the investigation, stated that he did not trust management, and declined to assist in resolving the problems. He was subsequently charged with gross negligence, dishonesty and bringing the company’s name into disrepute, and was dismissed in March 2019.


The employee referred an unfair dismissal dispute to the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA). The Commissioner found that although the employee had been negligent, dismissal was too harsh a sanction and therefore substantively unfair. However, the Commissioner declined to reinstate him, finding that the relationship between the employee and senior management had broken down irretrievably. Instead, he was awarded 12 months’ compensation.


The employee then approached the LC to review the award. The LC found that the Commissioner had not provided sufficient evidence to justify refusing reinstatement and ordered that the employee be reinstated retrospectively.


The employer appealed the decision to the LAC under case number CA10/2024. In a judgment delivered on 19 June 2025, the Court held that the Commissioner had properly exercised her discretion when refusing reinstatement.


The Court emphasised that reinstatement is generally the primary remedy for unfair dismissal, but may be refused where continued employment would be intolerable. It found that the employee had made serious and unfounded allegations against senior management, refused to accept responsibility for the failed rollout, and displayed a lack of cooperation and insight into his conduct.


The LAC ultimately concluded that the objective facts demonstrated a complete breakdown in trust, making continued employment intolerable. The appeal succeeded, and the Labour Court’s reinstatement order was replaced with an order dismissing the review application.



This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance on protected disclosures, employment practices, or compliance obligations, consult a qualified labour law practitioner.


© 2026 Global Business Solutions (GBS). All rights reserved.


I'm attending #ALLU2026 banner of Prof. Jonathan Goldberg.

Stay ahead of South Africa’s changing labour law

South Africa’s workplace laws are reaching The Tipping Point. Join us at #ALLU2026 – the Annual Labour Law Update for a practical update on the latest case law, legislative changes, Employment Equity developments, AI in the workplace and the issues employers need to prepare for now.


Get the insight. Understand the impact. Make better workplace decisions.Register for #ALLU2026


View our upcoming events: Upcoming Events and Qualifications, like #ALLU2026; the AI Compass High Impact Workshop Series (Only 4 Sessions); New CCMA 2026 Rules Pop-Up December; Managing Absenteeism & Sick Leave Abuse December 2026; and the Annual Employment Conference #AEC2027.


*All workshops are offered as customised in-house training that can be presented virtually or on-site.

A banner on the AI Compass High Impact Series presented by GBS

Comments


bottom of page